For over 20 years the Plough and Stars has been a bastion of Cambridge
nightlife. Located midway between Harvard and Central Squares, the room
is barely wide enough for two tables and a path for the waiter, but it
has hosted some of the most exciting shows in Beantown. The closest thing
in town to a pub such as you'd find in London or Dublin, the Plough is
also a genuine neighborhood bar, and on any given night you'll find a
combination of college students, local blue-collar workers, rockers and
generation X types. It's this democratic demographic spread that makes
the Plough such a fun place to be. With a social mix like this folks tend
to let it all hang out, and the tight quarters makes for a warm and cozy
atmosphere. The bartenders, including Noel and Barry (the bartender with
the clean-shaven pate), are among the cities most capable and friendly.
I first started to frequent
the Plough regularly when Treat Her Right
began their residency there. The long series of weekly shows that they
played built up a steady crowd, and while they honed their chops and polished
their tunes they also cultivated the core group of loyal fans that would
stick with them throughout their career. Treat Her Right was a perfect
band for that room. Their blend of smokey blues and roots rock was made
for a cramped pub, and most nights ended with a stream of spent revelers
filing out, soaked with dance sweat and with broad smiles on their faces.
It made me think of what early London blues-rock shows must have been
like when groups like the Yardbirds, the Kinks and the Rolling Stones
held residencies at spots such as the Richmond Hotel. Or the early 60's
gigs in the US when the Kingsmen and their peers held sway as house bands.
When I interviewed Dave Alcott (AKA Dave Champagne) recently
and asked him what shows with THR were his favorites there was no hesitation:
"the early shows while we were still playing at the Plough were easily
the best...the band was unsigned, relatively unknown, it was still fresh
and we weren't afraid to experiment. There were a lot of things we tried
then that we couldn't or wouldn't later on when things took off".
I
can't remember how I ended up booking my own weekly shows at the Plough.
I had sat in a few times with Treat Her Right, either singing or playing
guitar on "Home of the Blues"- which I'd played with Dave during the short
time I was with Pink Cadillac. I'd also
started to become a regular for the THR, Hubcaps and Boogaloo Swamis shows,
and I thought it seemed like a cool way to break in a band. The only free
night at that point was Monday, so I booked a month's worth of Monday
shows. They went pretty good, and I kept on going for another month, then
another, until a year had gone by and I'd spent the start of every week
in the tiny space next to the Men's Room that passes for a stage at the
Plough. Every week was a bit better, and I tried new things. The highlight
of the year came around month four, when I began to invite one or two
guests to play a set, turning the night into a sort of variety show-cum-cabaret.
While I kept up that series things went grand- we would often have a line
going out the door and down the street waiting to get in, while the crowd
in the room turned over two to three times a night. This was during the
same time that I was working with Billy Ruane and Greg "Skeggie" Kendall
in Helldorado Productions, so there was a nice
cooperative overlap between the shows we booked at the Middle
East Restaurant and those I set up at the Plough. Acts and performers
shuttled back and forth from the Mondays at he Plough to the Tuesday nights
we started out with at the Middle East, and later the Sundays and Thursdays
as they were added to Helldorado's piece of the Middle East schedule.
The
"stage" at the Plough and Stars presents its own set of unavoidable variables,
and the tiny patch of real esatate that he band must occupy between the
Fir (Men's Room), the rear door and the side wall makes for a challenging
stage setup. As I faced the crowd there was a wall inches to my left,
the men's Room three or four feet to my right, the drummer just behind
me and just behind him the stairs leading down to the kitchen. Rather
than make playing there a drag, however, this arrangement creates a unique
interaction between the crowd and the band. It also helps musicians who
play the room to develop an acrobatic sense of movement and keen peripheral
vision. Try to keep from knocking over your double Stoli on the floor
as you pirouhette to the left to let a patron get to the bathroom, then
veer back right, barely avoiding crushing your strobe tuner and twisting
your guitar into an improbable position to keep from whacking it on the
mic stand, as you let the bartender whisk by with a mountainous stack
of dirty pint glasses, headed for the basement. I called the weekly shows
at the Plough "Gig Adversity Training" as a joke within the band,
but in truth those shows were as much fun as any I've ever done. Anybody
playing in a big band complaining about losing touch with the audience,
craving closeness, etc., need only set up a weekly gig at the Plough to
recapture all the intimacy possible between a band and an audience. Just
as importantly the guys who run the place, from George the owner to the
bartenders like Noel are all great people. They let the band do their
job, they do theirs, and there is never any bullshit power tripping beyond
that. I love those guys.
There have been many wonderful
moments at the Plough that I've enjoyed. The band I used was an ever-shifting
group of musicians that was regularly augmented by members of the audience.
Regulars included Mark Sandman, Kim Deal, Richie Parsons, Bucky Baer
and Marylou Lord. The band at one time or another featured Clark
"Dark" Goodpastor, John Shriver, Matt Burns, Vinnie Roberto, Dave "Bone"
Pedersen. It would be hard to put together a list of all the local
and out-of-town musicians who sat in during the 24 months of shows that
I played at the Plough over the next three years.
The best journalistic photograph
of those days at the Plough was written by Ted Widmer, in a Boston Phoenix
article entitled "A Tale of Two Nitespots", wherein he detailed a typical
night at the Plough when Kim Deal sped over via hackney carriage from
a Pixies show at Citi, played her traditional Plough guest spot, and then
jumped back into the cab to get back across the Charles River for the
second Pixies show. Ted, who is now in Washington writing Foreign Affairs
speeches for President Clinton (!), tells it better than I can. Take this
link to read that fine Ted Widmer article over in the Joe Harvard
Press Kit section.
As a postscript, I returned
to the Plough in the fall of 1999 to play a couple of Saturday night shows.
The band, alternately known as the Grey Mods, Old School Bitch (sorry, mom)
or just plain old Joe Harvard, was made up of drummer (and veteran Plough
alumni) Matt Burns, and bass player John Rosato, who'd been the four-string
man in the Local 22's when I played the Wednesday night series at
the Middle East back in Spring/Summer 1989. With the exception of the defection
of Robert, the bartender who poured libations for many of the old Monday
nite gigs, and who'd left the Plough to open his own bar- the People's Republic
-down the street, the ambience remained the same. The staff were still great,
the regulars still mingled comfortably with the newbies and students, and
the overall vibe was very cool. Only the fact that I live (car-less) in
New York City as of this writing (Dec. 99 ) has prevented me from continuing
the once-a-month Saturday series at the Plough. The room remains the most
un-trendy,relaxed place in Boston to hang out for an evening's entertainment
without having a dozen wannabee rock stars posing at every stool. Tell 'em
Joe sent you.